NHacker Next
  • new
  • past
  • show
  • ask
  • show
  • jobs
  • submit
▲Russia reportedly planned mass-casualty attack in Poland to be blamed on Ukraine (yahoo.com)
jcfrei 9 hours ago [-]
I traveled through the baltics in the beginning of october and also crossed the suwalki gap to check out the border tripoint in Vištytis (between russia, poland and lithuania). even though it's in the middle of nowhere and on the edge of some large forests there was a surprising number of polish border patrols.
buckwheatmilk 7 hours ago [-]
I live in a small town in the Suwalki gap. It's not a garrison but military presence is definitely increased.

I find it bizarre that Russia would try to do something that could escalate to a second front even though it's clear that EU is nowhere near the readiness of Ukraine. When a shahed type drone crosses our airspace we don't have nothing adequate to shoot it down so F16's are used to shoot em down with rockets that cost 20x as drone does.

Also the idea that Ukraine somehow organised some attack on Polish or Baltic states soil would never be bought by the local population and all the fingers would be pointed at Russia.

Not sure what their calculus is but it doesn't seem sound. Fight in Ukraine has bogged down, and there are reports that Russia is losing more ground than it is gaining. The stated goal to capture remaining Donbas areas by the end of the year is unrealistic.

So the real question is is what is the point of these operations.

Another point is that they can stage as many of these operations as they want and at some point somewhere it will work.

TFNA 6 hours ago [-]
As the other poster mentions, Poland and the Baltics would not be the target audience. There are enough Germans, for example, living a Russian-friendly social-media and media bubble that their belief in a nefarious Ukrainian plot would be enough to throw a spanner in the works of a united EU response.
onemoresoop 6 hours ago [-]
Who's to say they're not also doing that? Russia is in a tough position at the moment so they'd likely try whatever works. EU is already under turmoil provoked by either Russia or the US.
newprint 6 hours ago [-]
> I find it bizarre that Russia would try to do something that could escalate to a second front > Not sure what their calculus is but it doesn't seem sound.

Calculus is very simple: they are 100% sure that Europe and Poland will not escalate. Poland will not get into a conflict without involving NATO. RU is escalating the conflicts the same way: Someone/Something did something, they look stateless, it your problem. As long as this can be reformulated as attack with plausible deniability, they will act with immunity.

Stateless "Green Men" showed-up in my former homecountry, Moldova, in early 90s and started a conflicts. Same group of men, showed-up in Donbass in Ukraine during the first conflict and took down the passenger airplane. Same group of men is/was involved in the current conflict.

buckwheatmilk 6 hours ago [-]
> they are 100% sure that Europe and Poland will not escalate.

I do agree on that point that they will not try to escalate by attacking military targets in Kaliningrad but direct attack against NATO state would open so many possibilities. There could be a strong response in a form of new capabilities given to Ukraine, money that is frozen right now in Belgium could be taken. Both sides have room to escalate I just don't see the upside for Russia in doing so.

newprint 4 hours ago [-]
Russian drones been blowing up on NATO territory for a while now. If my memory serves me right, there were even few "accidental" casualties in a Polish village. Yeah, nothing was done about it. "Our drone malfunctioned. We wanted to hit Ukr., but wind was too strong and 20kg of armed TNT just flew into your territory. OOPS..."
jacquesm 7 hours ago [-]
Last time I was there (2 years ago now) there were SMS messages not to depart from the main road and warning signs all over the place, is it more relaxed now? (East of Augustow)
mrngld 6 hours ago [-]
I don't know if Poland has them, I know they've had a lot of international sales, but APKWS systems can make F16 drone intercepts actually somewhat affordable. Still more expensive when you account for F16 operating costs, but at least it's not a huge gap like what firing a Patriot or SM3 or SM6 would be.
consumer451 7 hours ago [-]
> Also the idea that Ukraine somehow organised some attack on Polish or Baltic states soil would never be bought by the local population and all the fingers would be pointed at Russia.

Agreed, but you would not be the target audience for these macabre theatrics. It would be a performance for others.

red-iron-pine 5 hours ago [-]
> Not sure what their calculus is but it doesn't seem sound.

if they had sound calculus 2022 would have happened. or wouldn't have played out like it did.

they're playing their hand hard now because Donald Trump is their last ace. Once the US drives him out, if there is not utter chaos or civil war in the US, the US will start heavily supplying the AFU again, and things will get worse.

Putin has no real way out of this war. Russia does have a way out, but the Siloviki strongman types -- no chance. Victory or death. The question is how desperate he'll get and if he's willing to start a war with the EU or do more than just talk about nukes.

tim333 2 hours ago [-]
I figure he could freeze the frontline and declare victory. It wouldn't be popular in Russia but it's an option.
engineer_22 6 hours ago [-]
maybe it's a psychological operation organized by Europe to look like the Russians were planning a false flag

or *maybe* it's a rogue faction within Russia planning a false flag against Poland as a psychological operation against Russian citizens

or, possibly - ukranians, posing as russians who are posing as ukranians - to influence Poland to aid Ukraine

6th gen warfare... just never can know for sure ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

hem777 5 hours ago [-]
“Can never know for sure” as a mindset is exactly what disinformation campaigns aim to achieve.

Often times, we can and do know for sure.

darkwi11ow 6 hours ago [-]
Yeah we all know about that rogue faction. It is called FSB.
jacquesm 7 hours ago [-]
That whole area is effectively a garrison.
pingou 10 hours ago [-]
That doesn't seem to make much sense. Why would Ukraine attack Poland? There may be some tensions between Poland and Ukraine, but there need to be some degree of plausibility to a false flag operation.

If that was real it would probably make Poland support Ukraine even more or even declare war on Russia.

avgDev 10 hours ago [-]
I have been to Poland just over a year ago, there are people who definitely are upset about Ukrainians in the country. I've heard complaints that country is giving them money, they are taking jobs and the women are stealing men. An attack might be hard to believe for an outsider, however, if you already have a negative view, it might further drive your opinion that helping Ukraine is bad.
onemoresoop 6 hours ago [-]
> ave been to Poland just over a year ago, there are people who definitely are upset about Ukrainians in the country. I've heard complaints that country is giving them money, they are taking jobs and the women are stealing men

There's similar sentiment in other Easter Eurpean countries and that is mainly caused by Moscow influences and social media propaganda.

red-iron-pine 5 hours ago [-]
why dance around it: Russia is aggressively funding and propagandizing the European right wing. They pay the AfD, Marine le Pen in France, the recently removed Hungarian asshole, etc.
hunterpayne 4 hours ago [-]
They fund extremists, not one specific side. Attitudes like this do Russia's job for it.
mindslight 10 hours ago [-]
> if you already have a negative view, it might further drive your opinion

Exactly. The goal isn't really to effect (create) what is uniformly considered to be true, but rather what some (likely small) subculture believes. This helps further entrench that subculture (providing one more example of how "Ukraine is the aggressor"), as well as uses up most of the air in the room for discussion in the larger context - as the nonsense point is repeatedly brought up and re-litigated in place of anything constructive/substantive. In other words, the ultimate goal of disinformation isn't to alter the truth, but rather to destroy confidence in there even being a truth.

seer 7 hours ago [-]
I’m honestly very frustrated that this pattern has been on display for decades already (most prominently in Russias bot farms, and the American political quagmire) but no countries really are thinking in terms of actually combating this.

Yes we should be afraid of authoritarian regimes that could use this new power, but we get these regimes if we do nothing as well. And we should be wary of “ministry of truth”, but we will get it eventually anyway, and we could at least try to make it a real one that works, than just blatant fear lies and propaganda.

Countries should be experimenting in taking this whole thing head on - some institution that has no executive powers but has information clearance powers? Creating _some_ space that is accepted and respected enough so that serious discussion can happen.

It saddens me that we are just sleepwalking into a much more sinister world and it seems things will get worse before people feel the need to make it better?

Maybe the 20th century _was_ the anomaly because of the world wars disrupting all the previous powers, and now we are going back to the mean of an unequal world, with AI effectively creating economical problems for _everybody_.

red-iron-pine 5 hours ago [-]
facebook could shut it down tomorrow. so could twitter. they know. google knows.

VPNs and proxies are only so effective, and after twitter opened up where the posters are located we now know they're not hiding behind them very often.

but their leadership is ideologically inclined to the hard right, and perhaps more importantly, propaganda pays -- and that stock price gotta go up

6 hours ago [-]
postepowanieadm 8 hours ago [-]
Not really: people believing in conspiracy theories won't change their mind, any sane person would not believe in such false flag operation. However, as I said in previous comment - if russians were to stage a fake Ukrainian attack on Królewiec from Polish territory they could use it to put a pressure on Poland - also taking into account current American president.
Brotkrumen 9 hours ago [-]
It's the same Kreml Propaganda that right wing groups are spouting in all western nations. Off the top of my head:

- spending money on Ukraine when we don't have enough for X - Ukrainians are Nazis - Russia is just defending against NATO aggression

And my favorite

- arming the Ukraine delays peace and kills more people

It's fucking everywhere

lossolo 9 hours ago [-]
In the case of Poland, it is just amplifying a signal that was already there. Every Pole can tell you that a major part of society had negative feelings about Ukrainians before the war started because of the UPA and its behaviour regarding that organization. There was almost a trade war in the year before the war between Poland and Ukraine, but people like to forget that because of the war. So negative sentiments had been there for over 50 years, since the Ukrainian genocide of Poles in Volhynia, which is still in the minds of many people, and since Ukraine still denies it and has denied exhumations for decades. Actually, the situation today is better than before the war, by that I mean that there is more positive sentiment about Ukrainians among the Polish population than before 2022. Propaganda in cases like this does not create issues, it just amplifies the ones that were already there.
0x1ch 7 hours ago [-]
"Ukrainians are Nazis"

I know it's not good to generalize, but buddy-up with a slavic diaspora and talk about race relations, then form your opinion on this. Nazis? Not all. Racist and prejudice? Lots, extremely but unspoken.

Lio 6 hours ago [-]
That's not been my first hand experience of Ukrainian refugees.

I have noticed many Russian bots trying to push this narrative online though.

That and the ol' "it's Ukraine's fault for not surrendering" guff.

Both seem like pretty obvious bullshit propaganda.

0x1ch 6 hours ago [-]
My friends are younger, came over in 2014 when Crimea was annexed, and as of late a lot of their family members coming over from the war. I love my Slav friends, but a lot of these guys are just as racist or prejudice as a white frat boy, but I wouldn't call them nazis lol.
hunterpayne 4 hours ago [-]
"a lot of these guys are just as racist or prejudice as a white frat boy, but I wouldn't call them nazis lol."

If you think this, I don't believe you know either a Slav or a "frat boy".

0x1ch 4 hours ago [-]
Okay? I have nothing to prove to you, random internet stranger. Getting called a russian bot for pointing out there is a bit of racism coming along with the culture that I have witnessed first hand... Even some dev from Kyiv left a comment about the culture back in 2014. Also mind you, I myself and the people I'm referring are all early 20s, not sure if that changes anything about your incorrect observation.

I'll keep enjoying pierogi and borsch with my slavs, sorry not sorry!

6 hours ago [-]
darkwi11ow 6 hours ago [-]
Ukraine had changed a lot since 2014. Soros stooges have had infiltrated all strata of society since then. No good old aryanism survives in such atmosphere.

Another issue for our old folk is how pervasive feminism had become. People nowadays can be outright cancelled for misogynistic comments. Folk who moved out around 2014 would not believe this, but nevertheless it is how it is.

Qiu_Zhanxuan 8 hours ago [-]
[flagged]
mb_72 8 hours ago [-]
The conflict resolves when Russia returns to it's borders pre-2014, and stops attacking, it's that simple.
hem777 8 hours ago [-]
Which one or part has an element of truth? As far as I can tell none of it does.
snapcaster 7 hours ago [-]
[flagged]
hem777 7 hours ago [-]
You missed all of it.

Money is not scarce. Spending it on defense (Ukraine) is spending it on “the country sending it”. Wrt “the second one”, claiming “all Ukrainians are” is just bullshit. Third is not in any way a logical extrapolation (from what?). And finally, there’s only one party who wants war and refuses peace.

None of those have an element of truth.

wat10000 7 hours ago [-]
There are several issues with the third one.

First, it's not at all clear that a quick defeat of Ukraine would save innocent lives. Russia has not been particularly kind in the territories it has conquered so far.

Second is the lesson of appeasement. Giving in to an aggressor can just mean a bigger, worse war later. Munich didn't hasten peace or save innocent lives. It's not at all clear that this would be a Munich, but it's also not clear that it wouldn't be. That logical extrapolation rests on the assumption that it wouldn't be a Munich, which is very much unproven.

saulapremium 7 hours ago [-]
"Recognizing" that won't resolve anything.
BigTTYGothGF 7 hours ago [-]
[flagged]
jacquesm 7 hours ago [-]
When were you there last time?
BigTTYGothGF 7 hours ago [-]
You might not have realized it but thanks to developments such as "the internet" and "photography" and "literacy" I can learn about the world in ways that don't require me to be physically present in a location.
jacquesm 7 hours ago [-]
No, you won't. You will see images that may or may not be truthful or that have been selected to distort. I've been there at least 10 times and I've just met perfectly normal people.
BigTTYGothGF 6 hours ago [-]
jacquesm 6 hours ago [-]
Yes, very representative 900 people remaining but Ukraine's army is ~5 million people 900K of which are active duty.

Did you know the US 'Secretary of War' has similar tattoos? Should we now judge all of the US by that?

The Dutch FvD has strong links to Neo-Nazism. I guess we're structurally aligned as well. And then we have AfD, Meloni, Le Pen etc. And never mind who finances all that.

lovich 7 hours ago [-]
You will find people with Nazi tattoos in every single western nation.

Seeing it on some Ukrainians doesn’t make Ukrainians in general Nazis or even a sizeable minority of them.

jacquesm 6 hours ago [-]
Pro-russian propaganda goes completely wild on this, it has become a central plank in their messaging: "we're the good guys, we're fighting the Nazi's, again.".

FWIW I think Ukraine could do better here (as well as in their relations with Poland) but to claim that this is structural is ridiculous. The main reason russians are pissed at Azov is because they didn't give up and that in turn made them far more visible than they would have been otherwise.

cromka 9 hours ago [-]
Agreed. And dare mentioning the GDP growth they bring in!
snapcaster 7 hours ago [-]
[flagged]
SetTheorist 7 hours ago [-]
All of them
hem777 7 hours ago [-]
All of them and no.
RicoElectrico 10 hours ago [-]
Basically the narrative of both Konfederacja parties on TikTok.
thaumasiotes 9 hours ago [-]
> and the women are stealing men

Considering the sex ratio of people leaving Ukraine, you could hardly have any other result.

bialpio 8 hours ago [-]
Those poor men, they have no agency, they are being stolen! /s

You can't steal what's being freely given, and another person is not yours to be stolen from you.

avgDev 5 hours ago [-]
Ah it does cause some issues. Better looking Ukrainian women can go for lesser men just to get their documents because that is better than nothing. Therefore, some average Polish women can have a harder time finding a mate.

This is why below average men can travel to 3rd world countries and date beautiful women.

edgyquant 6 hours ago [-]
I mean, this is totally ignoring realities that there are only so many people of each sex and if you bring in hundreds of thousands of mostly women into a monogamous country there will be losers that otherwise wouldn’t have been.
ajuc 7 hours ago [-]
Far right everywhere in the world supports russia - see MAGA, AfD, LePen, Farage, Orban. Same in Poland.

They are all trying to destroy the "liberal world order" and replace it with "multipolar world" (AKA everybody's a dictatorship and there's no rules for oligarchs).

tim333 2 hours ago [-]
I'm not sure Farage for instance is that into multipolar and dictatorships. That lot are mostly kind of anti immigration and a bit racist and Russia has similar views and gives them money. It's mostly about money including "We have all the funding we need out of Russia" Trumps.

Russia also helps send loads of refugees to help the anti immigration lot get elected https://www.lbc.co.uk/article/russia-helping-smugglers-europ...

lesspassiveobse 4 hours ago [-]
I'm from Poland and this is completely false
throwaway5752 7 hours ago [-]
Yes, it's much easier to steal from or defeat people when they are divided. This is straight out of Sun Tzu 2600 years ago, nothing new here. Just better tools to manipulate the pliable.
mathgeek 7 hours ago [-]
Good to remember that we are all pliable.
throwaway5752 5 hours ago [-]
Volgodonsk, 1999
5 hours ago [-]
jltsiren 7 hours ago [-]
Russia is one of the biggest issues dividing far right parties around the world.

Nationalism is a funny ideology. When two nationalists meet, ideological alignment can make them anything between best friends and worst enemies, depending on national interests.

mrngld 6 hours ago [-]
Being aligned to your own nations interests didn't used to be called nationalism, it used to be called normal. Even ideological foes can occasionally have aligned goals. Nationalism, in that sense, is just prioritizing the place you live, not some sort of left/right ideology that you should expect some international alignment on.
TFNA 6 hours ago [-]
Eastern European nationalism of the sort the OP alluded to is a lot more than just "being aligned to your own nation's interest". For example, it often entails irredentism where one demands back lands that once belonged to the country, merely appealing to history, even though almost none of the titular ethnicity still lives on that land and it wouldn't even bring an economic benefit (and it might even be within Schengen so it's not like there are borders anyway). It can mean that in a multilingual country, only one ethnicity's language is privileged, which isn't in the interest of the rest of the nation. It can mean ugly antisemitism, where everything is blamed on Jewish conspiracy even though there aren't many Jews around since WWII and '68, etc.
hunterpayne 4 hours ago [-]
You aren't wrong. However, being a bit nationalist is just normal and rational. What is extreme are the internationalists that you see popping up on the left these days. That isn't a rational nor a workable ideology but you see plenty of people espousing it. Ignoring this to focus on the very silly parts of eastern European nationalist politics isn't all that helpful.

The recent change in the Serbian government for example wasn't explicitly nationalistic, it was about corruption. The old government was pretty nationalistic but the new one isn't much less nationalistic. The old government was unpopular because of corruption, not because it was nationalism. Being anti-corruption is the more popular position in eastern Europe. That nationalism part is just normal people being concerned for the society in which they live. It isn't wanting to invade your neighbor because of some weird behavior with a glass bottle.

Zanfa 10 minutes ago [-]
The sort of nationalists that are a problem, don’t have their nations interests in mind. Typically they’ve just appropriated a nations symbols to (completely coincidentally of course) push conspiracy theories, misinformation, anti-EU and NATO positions and generally Russian-friendly talking points, draped in extraneous amount of national symbolism, and general corruption.

It’s the same playbook all over.

kakacik 9 hours ago [-]
Yes there are maga-equivalents all over the world and predominantly in rural settings, including every single european state. Roughly 5-30% of the population depending where.

They all repeat the same thing like a broken record also across countries and continents since stories originate in same fsb offices, no critical thinking, not even any form of discussion can be had, you can only repeat same chants or be instantly labeled as manipulated stupid/evil outsider of the echo chambers. Its funny sometimes to hear stuff clearly intended for US population being spouted by some eastern european fellow who doesn't even have a clue what he talks about but the zeal is there nevertheless.

Women stealing men lol thats a good one, lets have a moment of silence for poor polish bros being hunted by attractive ladies from left and right (some anthem playing in the background, flags down etc).

pixl97 8 hours ago [-]
Heh, I remember some "warm water port" stuff being spouted talking about Texas. Yea, people in the US don't talk like that because all of our major ports are warm water ports and the ocean doesn't even get close to freezing in the south. Propaganda straight from Russia.
Zanfa 7 hours ago [-]
> Its funny sometimes to hear stuff clearly intended for US population being spouted by some eastern european fellow who doesn't even have a clue what he talks about but the zeal is there nevertheless.

It works the other way around as well, eg Marjorie Taylor Greene‘s sudden concern with the Transcarpathian minorities in Ukraine.

eleumik 8 hours ago [-]
Ya that is horror, catholic guys talking evangelical, if you're poor is your fault and even "no pension !"
snapcaster 7 hours ago [-]
agreed on MAGA types being stupid and gullible, but where do you think your ideas originate? Is Langley better than FSB offices?
wat10000 7 hours ago [-]
First of all, I'd like to think I have at least some independent thoughts. Secondly, yes, Langley is better than FSB offices. Neither is good but if we're going to make the comparison then let's actually look at it.
hunterpayne 4 hours ago [-]
That isn't how intelligence operations work. They don't care about ideology. They magnify or minimize whatever groups and ideas they think will accomplish their goals. This idea that ideology or politics all originates from an intelligence service is pants on head dumb. They can push narratives a bit one way or another, but if a population doesn't believe an idea, an intelligence operation won't change that.
senderista 9 hours ago [-]
It doesn't help when Ukraine is still giving medals to people who helped genocide Poles in WW2.
nsoam 8 hours ago [-]
[flagged]
rdtsc 9 hours ago [-]
> Why would Ukraine attack Poland?

They were not historically as friendly as you may imagine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volhynian_Bloody_Sunday

In light of the war with Russia, Ukrainian govt has been leaning more into bolstering various individuals from the past who have had nationalistic leanings (you can read that in any flavor you'd like).

(from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ukrainian_Insurgent_Army)

> On 20 October 2026, local deputies of the Lviv Regional Council supported a resolution to designate 2027 as the Year of the Ukrainian Insurgent Army (UPA) and its commander-in-chief, Roman Shukhevych.

It's kind of a sensitive topic, certainly, and the Russians will not fail to take advantage of this crack and try to "widen" it a bit, if you will. A false flag attack is a pretty bold move. Don't know if it means they are desperate.

kakacik 8 hours ago [-]
Dude these are details in the face of current war where both are facing the enemy which brought genocide and annihilation on industrial scale to their population in the recent past. Sort of proven mortal enemy for both nations at this point. Whatever ukrainians did in the past soviets/russians brought 100x more.

Sure it can be picked up later, but apart from few sour individuals and few political games this is an afterthought and gives 0 actual reasons for any actual hostilities.

renw0rp 7 hours ago [-]
Dude, the estimate civilian casualties (dead) in Ukraine are around 20k. Estimated 50-100k civilians were killed by Ukrainians during WW2 (the range is so imprecise because years of hiding this fact during communist times and denial of exhumations even in the years after).
Emma_Goldman 10 hours ago [-]
The story is that the attack would have been on the Polish border with Kaliningrad, an exclave Russian territory. To have any plausibility, I suppose it would have to attack shared infrastructure, of which there's not much, or been staged as an accident.

Of course, this is unconfirmed and garbled. It comes third or fourth hand from an English-language source relaying a Polish source relaying Polish intelligence acquired from foreign intelligence services.

meuman 8 hours ago [-]
Russia wages cognitive war against the west, especially on Poland. There are plenty of people who dislike Ukrainians because of these actions. Openly pro-russian and anti-ukrainian political parties have about 8% now, so go figure.
theseamusjames 7 hours ago [-]
And as much of the world has shown, if they can grow that number to 30% it's often enough to take some or all of the power in a country through other political maneuvering. They don't need everyone to believe it. They just need enough people to be unsure that 1 in 3 thinks it _could_ be true. And they don't need to take control forever, just a few years without international support would make things so much harder for Ukraine.
pavel_lishin 10 hours ago [-]
It's nearly impossible to have any sort of theory about this without knowing the details, which are obviously not going to be shared out any time soon.
postepowanieadm 8 hours ago [-]
Ukrainians using Polish territory to launch an attack on russia could cause some tensions.
ted_bunny 7 hours ago [-]
They are already using Baltic airspace. They want to pull Europe and the US in.
jacquesm 6 hours ago [-]
Europe and the US are already in even if some of us are reluctant to understand this. And no, they don't use Baltic airspace. Don't talk nonsense.
ted_bunny 6 hours ago [-]
They're in it in a proxy capacity, not fully in it. Ukrainians rightfully don't want to be the only ones dying.

And the Baltic thing is already confirmed. At least google it before you deny it outright, unless you don't value your credibility.

jacquesm 6 hours ago [-]
I'm sure you have your sources...

Meanwhile: https://uatv.ua/en/ukraine-does-not-use-baltic-states-airspa...

Russia would love it if they did though.

ted_bunny 3 hours ago [-]
Why would Russia love that? They do not want war with all of Europe, they're not suicidal cartoon villains as many would have you believe
jacquesm 3 hours ago [-]
> they're not suicidal cartoon villains as many would have you believe

No, they're the suicidal cartoon villains that are on display every day, there isn't anything to believe here.

Anyway, it's clear that you don't have an argument or you would have certainly brought it.

As for why Russia would love it: they've been provoking the EU for years now hoping for some kind of direct response, so clearly if they had proof that Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania or Finland were directly involved in attacks on russia that they would spin it to their advantage. The only reason we're not in all-out world-war-III right now is because NATO has - so far - refused to be baited.

ted_bunny 3 hours ago [-]
They are taking nearly equal losses in Ukraine, and you think they want to go to war with Europe and the US? Sorry, but that is ludicrous. There is little I can say to bridge the gap of our sets of beliefs when you accept a dehumanizing worldview.
jacquesm 2 hours ago [-]
I am not sure if you are following russian media but they are in their own view already at war with the West. So it may be 'ludicrous' to you but on the other side of that line it apparently makes perfect sense. Just today there was a potential false flag on Polish territory involving the area around Kaliningrad.

https://www.thetimes.com/world/europe/article/russia-plotted...

None of this makes sense when you're thinking logically, but neither does it make sense to destroy your country, its standing in the world and your relationships with all of your neighbors and yet, here we are.

whoanoway 2 hours ago [-]
[dead]
ted_bunny 2 hours ago [-]
tremon 2 hours ago [-]
[dead]
jacquesm 2 hours ago [-]
I'm going on the assumption that you've actually read the page you are linking, and if you did then I don't understand why you think it bolsters your argument.
slibhb 7 hours ago [-]
The gameplan could've been: attack Poland, but make it look like the attack was carried out by Ukrainians and meant to target Kaliningrad but missed. Or the attack could've actually been on Kaliningrad itself, made to look as if Ukraine was using Poland to launch an attack.

Consider that the Russians very likely blew up the Nord Stream pipeline (between Germany and Russia) and convinced plenty of people that Ukraine was behind it.

ted_bunny 7 hours ago [-]
What would be the Russian motive for blowing up the Nordstream? What convinces you they did it?
slibhb 6 hours ago [-]
It's not clear who did it, but I think it was probably Russia. You can read about it:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nord_Stream_pipelines_sabotage...

ted_bunny 2 hours ago [-]
What makes you sure enough to say? Certainly not this link. I simply cannot see a reason for them to do so - their supply of natural gas paid an economic and peace dividend with Europe. A cui bono analysis would hold far more water than the haystack of claims in this article.
1234sag 6 hours ago [-]
> Consider that the Russians very likely blew up the Nord Stream pipeline (between Germany and Russia) and convinced plenty of people that Ukraine was behind it.

It is really remarkable. Yesterday I was happy that Ukraine took down the Kerch bridge.

Today I am reading such blatant propaganda again that I wonder if there is any difference between Ukraine and Russia.

kergonath 10 hours ago [-]
> That doesn't seem to make much sense. Why would Ukraine attack Poland?

The aims of Russia here is to sow doubt and distrust. It does not need to be bulletproof, just muddy enough to provide talking points for their agents and useful idiots. The relationship between Poland and Ukraine is… complicated. What brings them together is mostly that they hate Russia more.

darksaints 6 hours ago [-]
Russian propaganda makes people believe stupid things
dmos62 10 hours ago [-]
You can spin it in social media and lots of people will believe it. It's unreal to me too, but disinformation is super effective and Russia is expert at it. You don't need the majority to believe it, anything to fuel division is enough.
PorciiVorbesc 9 hours ago [-]
edit: good point type0, forgot about that
type0 9 hours ago [-]
Information in Russia is tightly controlled

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roskomnadzor

benterix 9 hours ago [-]
>That doesn't seem to make much sense

Neither does SIM cards presented as The Sims games:

https://nypost.com/2022/04/25/russia-appears-to-confuse-the-...

But it doesn't matter, they do it anyway and are quite effective as the far right has considerable support in various parts of Europe.

saalweachter 10 hours ago [-]
Double false flag? Maybe it was supposed to be Russians pretending to be Ukrainians pretending to be Russians, to make it look like Russia was being framed for attacking Poland in an attempt to increase Polish support for the war, so that when the one layer of false-flag was peeled back it would create a backlash against Ukraine?
lifestyleguru 10 hours ago [-]
With such smart people on Polish, Ukrainian, and Russian sides one thing is certain - billions will be stolen and defrauded.
ozim 9 hours ago [-]
You are smart.

Now explain the same to dozens of stupid people who will see “evidence” from the site to fuel disinformation and then all the stupid people who will pass that disinformation.

Then take casualties into account - you think that relatives of people killed in such attack will analyze geopolitical environment when they they are pointed to “obvious evidence”?

That’s naivety.

alephnerd 10 hours ago [-]
The aim was to kill a couple Russian citizens and then blame Ukraine via plausible deniability [0].

Tactically, it likely would have been paying a couple Ukrainians working in the black market (sadly very common across Europe) to conduct a high casualty event on Russian civilians in Kalinigrad and Poland and then blame it on Ukraine via a mixture of money trail and metadata.

A good example of this is the 2025 Pahalgam attack [1] in Indian Kashmir which led to the 2025 Indo-Pak War - India had a difficult time building the diplomatic case for the conflict because of plausible deniability from the attackers.

Some HNers just don't realize how precarious stuff is at the moment [2].

[0] - https://www.rp.pl/konflikty-zbrojne/art45490041-prowokacja-z...

[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2025_Pahalgam_attack

[2] - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50538994#50539922

Tanjreeve 9 hours ago [-]
It doesn’t matter if i makes sense. You just need to sow enough confusion for actions to get bogged down in debate. Same as when russia invaded in 2014 and english speaking social media was utterly saturated with how this was a spontaneous local militia who had overwhelmed the Ukranian army and somehow aquired the latest special forces equipment.
ted_bunny 7 hours ago [-]
If you decide that you never need to attribute rational motives to your opponents' actions, you are opening the door to accept nearly any claim about them.
ajuc 8 hours ago [-]
> there need to be some degree of plausibility to a false flag operation

Was there any plausibility to russia annexing crimea with russian uniforms, tanks, SAM systems etc presenting them as homegown ukrainian rebels?

It's just throwing shit at a wall.

mzs 9 hours ago [-]
https://tvpworld.com/96545106/russia-planned-false-flag-atta...

But Moscow could have accused Ukraine of attacking Russia from Polish territory, blamed Warsaw for allowing it and threatened retaliation.

Or Russia could even have launched a subsequent attack on a target in Poland, the alleged source of the Ukrainian attack. This would have confronted NATO with a serious crisis, while Moscow could claim to have been defending itself.

This is precisely the sort of test of NATO solidarity that allied leaders have warned about.

By manufacturing uncertainty over who attacked whom, Moscow could have sown doubts among member states, delayed a collective response and exposed divisions over whether Article 5 should be invoked.

...

The methods are becoming increasingly brazen. Earlier this month, Polish investigators arrested two Ukrainians accused of setting vehicles alight on Russian orders, having first fitted them with number plates resembling those of the Ukrainian army.

Prosecutors believe the idea was to turn Polish public opinion against Ukraine.

OkayPhysicist 7 hours ago [-]
Picture this:

A vehicle, carrying some moderately high ranking Russian official is driving through Poland, bound for Kaliningrad, gets ambushed by unknown assailants at a stoplight. One vehicle pulls in front of the convoy, two more pull up behind it. A half dozen gunmen open fire from all angles, spraying automatic rifle fire through the target vehicle. The convoy's security draw their sidearms and return fire, immediately dropping 3 of the attackers. The remaining attackers pull back to one of the vehicles, dumping suppressing fire to cover their retreat. Once in their vehicle, they punch it. Jumping the curb, they plow through a couple of bystanders who were huddled behind a bus stop for cover from the chaos. They disappear into the city. In the aftermath, 2 attackers are dead, one is gravely injured and taken prisoner by the Russians. 2 of the defenders are in critical condition, but expected to pull through. Miraculously, the target official was able to duck down before bullets started flying, and only received superficial injuries. Nearly a dozen bystanders were not that lucky. A family of four, driving home from a family outing to a local museum found themselves in the unenviable position of being pulled up beside the official's vehicle when the shooting started. Pictures of a bleeding child holding his sister's lifeless body in front of a bullet-ridden, bloodstained car run nonstop in the news cycle for the next week. The adult daughter of a little old lady who was run over during the attacker's escape gives a sobbing interview about how Nana never hurt a fly, and how she had so many years ahead of her, caring for her darling grandchildren. A young man recounts how he was sitting across the street, having a lovely date with his childhood crush who he had just reconnected with, when a stray bullet tore straight through her neck, and how powerless he felt watching her drop like a marionette with cut strings.

In the days that follow, Polish officials are slow to attribute blame, because they know damn well that the Russians aren't above this sort of false flag operation. But social media is ablaze with no shortage of people spreading "the truth". It's obvious, they argue. The target was a Russian intelligence officer. The attackers were shouting orders to one another in Ukrainian. Clearly this was a Ukranian assassination plot, planned with little regard for Polish lives.

TFNA 6 hours ago [-]
This is not a comment informed about this region. Even moderately ranking Russian officials would never transit overland through Poland to Kaliningrad. This would require Poland's approval, and obviously such would not be granted. Flights connect Kaliningrad and mainland Russia daily, that is how officials go between.
OkayPhysicist 2 hours ago [-]
Then substitute the Russian official for a Russian-sympathizing political Polish political figure. The story plays the same.
TFNA 2 hours ago [-]
Again, I don't believe you have any actual familiarity with this region.
margalabargala 6 hours ago [-]
Certainly that is the reality.

Would that truth stop the bot-fueled social media fervor that would accompany a Russian false flag attack like the one described?

I doubt it.

mik1998 10 hours ago [-]
[flagged]
pepperoni_pizza 10 hours ago [-]
1) It is not really proven that Ukraine did that.

2) Nordstream is Russian infrastructure.

jkman 9 hours ago [-]
Even if you could be sure that that is what occurred, to characterize it as "an attack on its allies" is completely nonsensical
madspindel 9 hours ago [-]
Of course it was Ukraine and not grodmän from HMS Gotland!
oska 3 hours ago [-]
Quoting the Guidelines :

> Off-Topic: Most stories about politics, or crime, or sports, or celebrities, unless they're evidence of some interesting new phenomenon. If they'd cover it on TV news, it's probably off-topic.

If the readership of HN continues to allow (i.e. not flag) and even upvote stories on military conflicts which are highly politicised and propagandised then the utility of HN will diminish

tim333 2 hours ago [-]
It's a somewhat interesting phenomenon. The Telegraph reports it a bit differently that the Russians were planning to kill Russian civilians in Kaliningrad and blame it on the Poles. https://www.telegraph.co.uk/world-news/2026/11/18/russia-pla...

Don't know if there's been much Russians killing Russians to blame someone for politics since Putin had the KGB blow up Russian flats to get elected when he first came to power?

_DeadFred_ 2 hours ago [-]
HN management officially opened the door with IP discussion and making it a special official exception/exemption. HN users normalizing the exception and/or ignorong 'special/preferred conflicts only' says something.
garbawarb 10 hours ago [-]
I'm surprised that almost no English-language sources seem to have picked up the story yet.
pndy 9 hours ago [-]
The story arrived around 10 in the morning (UTC+1) in Poland, IIRC
dualvariable 9 hours ago [-]
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/world-news/2026/11/18/russia-pla...

Other newspapers are probably trying to do actual journalism and meet their sourcing requirements, as old-fashioned as that seems, rather than just immediately run with reporting on what Rzeczpospolita reported.

azan_ 7 hours ago [-]
Who would know better than RP?
Tade0 9 hours ago [-]
I'm Polish and I've only heard about Russian operatives concentrating close to the Polish-Russian border recently, who were matched by an equal number of Polish operatives.

The Russians either wanted to be spotted, or didn't think this would prompt further analysis on the Polish side.

9 hours ago [-]
dprkh 8 hours ago [-]
Don't worry, they are just training.
yetihehe 7 hours ago [-]
In case someone didn't understand parent's joke: Some Russian soldiers were even convinced that they were on training when they entered into Ukraine in first days of war.
yodon 9 hours ago [-]
> Russian intelligence services reportedly planned to carry out a sabotage operation on Polish territory near the border with Russia's Kaliningrad Oblast in late October or early November which they intended to be blamed on Ukraine
Gys 10 hours ago [-]
Impossible to read because the page keeps refreshing (and jumping to the top) every few seconds. Iphone latest OS, Firefox
mzs 10 hours ago [-]
emil-lp 10 hours ago [-]
Firefox has reader mode. Use that.
pushcx 8 hours ago [-]
On mobile, Firefox waits for the page to settle before displaying the button, so it doesn't work on pages that reload or fail to load.
PeterWhittaker 9 hours ago [-]
Latest iOS and Safari are fine. FF issue? Or yahoo-hates-FF issue?
petre 8 hours ago [-]
Not much to read anyway. They just say they foiled some kind of false flag attack with many casualties that was supposed to be like the Gleiwitz incident.

Dunno, but Poland and Lithuania should just each build a border fence, put dragon teeth along it and a border road that is patrolled 24/7 with armed guards and border patrol K9 units. The Finnish just know better.

https://raja.fi/en/the-eastern-border-barrier-fence

binvader 5 hours ago [-]
Which they actually doing at the moment. Poland will invest ~9B Eur within a few years to border defense. Lithuania has a confirmed territory for a new military training ground nearby. Not so easy when you have hundreds of kilometers of "bad neighbours", takes time. And yes, Finns know better, but they had 50 years of head start...
MisterTea 4 hours ago [-]
> The Finnish just know better.

Poland was a Soviet puppet state from 1952 to 1989.

xrd 8 hours ago [-]
I just watched the movie 20 days in Mariupol.

Those images will never leave me.

And, what really maddened me was Russian officials lying about attacking hospitals and then trying to say pregnant women hit by shrapnel, and later dying, were just actors. You can see from the video footage and doctor testimony that this was a total lie.

In the age of information and disinformation, we need new Nuremberg trials to shine a spotlight on the cost of lying.

entropie 6 hours ago [-]
> I just watched the movie 20 days in Mariupol.

I started it 3 times and never finished it. Its to rough.

xrd 2 hours ago [-]
I agree.

It should be required viewing for any US politician.

zeroq 7 hours ago [-]
[flagged]
hunterpayne 4 hours ago [-]
If you think those two situations are the same, you really really need to get better news sources. Ukraine didn't charge across an international border and kill random civilians for example. They were invaded and don't have a history of killing Russian civilians, especially in Russia. That's a huge difference. If you don't see that, there is something very wrong with you.
zeroq 4 hours ago [-]
Wait, did Venezuela attacked US? Did Iran killed American civilians?

Do you have any idea what's going on in Palestine?

hunterpayne 3 hours ago [-]
I clearly understand all of those situations better than you. To answer your questions:

1) Maduro's VP sold him out, so nobody wanted him to stick around 2) Iran has killed US civilians on many occasions. Your ignorance isn't a good argument 3) October 7th happened

Going through life led around by your emotions and ignorance isn't strategy nor good policy.

AnimalMuppet 9 hours ago [-]
Near border with Kaliningrad, but pretending to be caused by Ukraine? The nearness to Kaliningrad may have made it operationally easier, but it might also have been a bit of a tell...
ReptileMan 9 hours ago [-]
[flagged]
antagma 8 hours ago [-]
[dead]
ChrisArchitect 10 hours ago [-]
Title is: Russia reportedly planned mass-casualty sabotage attack in Poland to be blamed on Ukraine
Krasnol 7 hours ago [-]
Looks like desensitization to me.

I bet the moment Russia would actually attack something on NATO territory, Vatniks and politicians from the usual Right-Wing parties and their media would say that this was a false flag by Ukraine.

nowreally 6 hours ago [-]
Most probably a western provocation. Scope: "freeing" Kaliningrad, it is a long time many lithuanians and poles dreaming about this (there are normal people there of course, as everywhere: but when the Big Brother encourages nationalists and revanchists, this is what happens).

Remember Nordstream, and how "it were the Russians, it is how they act"? ..the west still claims though these were "ukranians" (and some even believe that..)

throw310822 9 hours ago [-]
It's astonishing how many terrorist plots from enemy nations are thwarted before causing damages or victims; and always in ways that makes clear who was planning them. From Iran's plan to detonate a dirty bomb in the US, to a "mass casualty" false flag by Russia in Poland.. you'd think that these countries, ever so clumsy in devising their evil schemes, always unmasked and revealed for the arch-villains they are, would at some point realise how much damage they are inflicting on themselves and desist. But no, they stubbornly insist and never succeed, like cartoon characters. Curious.
kakacik 8 hours ago [-]
You are confusing quite a few things. russia is actively attacking government facilities across western Europe for a decade+ successfully. Vrbetice in Czech republic for example, you even have 2 specific FSB agents sentenced for the bombings killing staff. Same for Romania. Poisonings in UK. And so on.

They are quite good, I wouldn't denigrate them just because they are on the side of war waged by incompetent corrupt ass lickers. Not top notch like CIA or Mosad but still pretty good and can and do cause mayhem almost anywhere in the world if they want.

blks 8 hours ago [-]
And how many terrorist attacks are never called “terrorist”, like USA blowing up school full of children in Iran.
simion314 9 hours ago [-]
>But no, they stubbornly insist and never succeed, like cartoon characters. Curious.

You are wrong, plenty of "special operations" from FSB paid idiots succeded , like this example in my country https://militarnyi.com/en/news/ukrainian-arrested-in-poland-...

So your NEVER claim is FALSE, I dare you to admit it to yourself no need to admit it publicly, one step at a time. (just in the chance you are not a Zed)

whoanoway 9 hours ago [-]
[dead]
madaxe_again 9 hours ago [-]
They should have tried to blame it on Jensen Huang. Then people would be more likely to believe it.
nikolay 7 hours ago [-]
[flagged]
hem777 6 hours ago [-]
“Russophobia” is not a thing.
nikolay 6 hours ago [-]
[flagged]
hem777 5 hours ago [-]
That is the exactly the myth.

“If there is one word that gives the signal that a media outlet is clearly pro-Kremlin, it is “Russophobia””

https://euvsdisinfo.eu/the-russophobia-myth-appealing-to-the...

See also:

https://euvsdisinfo.eu/report/russophobia-is-a-political-too...

nikolay 5 hours ago [-]
[flagged]
hem777 5 hours ago [-]
No, that’s not what links say nor is the source British. Read on and you’ll find that “Russophobia” is a propaganda tool used and invented by Russia.
flohofwoe 7 hours ago [-]
> ...with no showers, not toilets...

...so just like 95% of Russia in peace time? ;P

nikolay 6 hours ago [-]
[flagged]
flohofwoe 5 hours ago [-]
Well you guys worked really hard to get there, so...
antagma 9 hours ago [-]
[flagged]
jkman 9 hours ago [-]
Absolutely absurd read of the situation currently, historical facts, etc. I can only imagine that you're a bot, else you should refrain from opening your mouth on things you don't understand.
abrichr 8 hours ago [-]
Could you please clarify which claim you think is wrong? Not choosing sides, just interested in substantive discussion.
isthisso 8 hours ago [-]
[flagged]
hem777 7 hours ago [-]
Which provocations do you mean precisely?
darkwi11ow 8 hours ago [-]
This happens because current government has put russia into a weak position. No one was provoking them when they had sane leadership.
8 hours ago [-]
lifestyleguru 10 hours ago [-]
[flagged]
NicoJuicy 9 hours ago [-]
Russia can only be thwarted by strength.

Civilians need to be aware of the threat, so the country can arm itself, so Russia won't dare to do anything.

Russia may be much weaker than people thought 10 years ago. It's still a couple of million Putin can put in the meat grinder.

kakacik 8 hours ago [-]
Its a mafia pyramid of power all the way to the top. So yes only power of stronger decides how they behave and written contracts are worth nothing long term. Look at consistent ass licking towards Xi, there its pretty clear who is the big boy and who the lapdog.

Country arming itself now won't thwart russians though. Maybe on level of Swiss for example (everybody has rifle home / nearby and necessary training, effectively having cca 35% of the population as part of the army). Thats not feasible in next 5 years when major russian attack against Nato (ie Baltics) is expected. Also, now its mainly drone battlefield.

jkman 9 hours ago [-]
Are you Russian or something? What the hell is this take
lifestyleguru 9 hours ago [-]
[flagged]
Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact
Rendered at 02:33:40 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time) with Vercel.