This is really cute! I've had an idea floating around in my head for a while to build a "Little Free Digital Library" inspired by the Little Free Libraries people build in their front yards. It would be a solar powered raspberry pi that hosts a private (offline) wifi network where you can browse and dowload from the host's curated book collection. A great way to share my favorite books from gutenberg or standard ebooks.
1 hours ago [-]
philips 6 hours ago [-]
I really like this idea. I imagine it is a a decade too early as I feel pocket ereaders are just taking off.
scirob 7 hours ago [-]
I like the framing. And framing matters. Telegram is full of priated content shows and books and also a place to buy drugs but since the app's main users just message their friends it can live on all appstores.
My positive spin
philips 6 hours ago [-]
I submitted this because I found the idea inspiring.
That said…
I think it would be better if the library cards were public keys and I set the access controls on a list of keys. The card numbering seems underbaked.
The practical problem this solves in practice is there are lots of ereaders that have opds and wifi but can’t access things over tailscale or equivalent.
fg137 8 hours ago [-]
So plex/jellyfin but for books.
I personally don't know anyone who hosts plex server of files ripped from legitimately acquired media, or anyone that uses such a server from an actual friend. If someone does, and wants to do the same for books, all the power to them.
Realistically though, I'd expect someone who doesn't buy or borrow a book (from a library, friend, or ebook from Libby) will go straight to Anna's Archive or z library. I yet need to meet someone who nicely asks their reader friend to share epub of a de-DRMed book.
(ok, in plain words, the most likely use case for this is piracy, but with more steps.)
cowlevel 6 hours ago [-]
For legal reasons, I do know people who use Plex to manage their legally purchased DVD library. It is useful software which does not primarily facilitate piracy.
trescenzi 3 hours ago [-]
There’s other tools for that as well. I like Grimmory for example. This looks more like a thinner client intended to mostly be consumed through OPDS, simple standard for sharing/selling ebooks, on an ereader. This seems more about building community and not just sharing ebooks.
I do know one who likes to share their (ebook and audiobook) library around, although they just use the usual file sharing solutions.
I guess it's similar to lending a paper book to a friend.
reorder9695 5 hours ago [-]
I actually do use Jellyfin for ripped media, I had a lot of DVDs and was worried about disc rot and frankly it was more convenient as well to have them available on my phone too, so I spent a weekend ripping most of them.
close04 7 hours ago [-]
I think this is more like Plex, with the sharing features and external access. I use Calibre Web personally and that seems more like Jellyfin, with no central identity or much sharing. Perfect for self hosting.
AtomicSaboteur 5 hours ago [-]
I find it weird that the branch code is open-source, but the "main" code is not.
cgsmith 9 hours ago [-]
Is this... legal? For public domain books of course it is but there are legal issues for letting friends "borrow" and epub since they are just getting a copy. I would love to be corrected.
justusthane 8 hours ago [-]
No, but since it’s meant for private sharing among friends the impact and potential to get in trouble is probably quite limited.
More like burning a CD for a friend than sharing an album via a torrent.
blfr 6 hours ago [-]
If it's genuinely limited to your social circle, it would be legal in Poland for example.
justusthane 6 hours ago [-]
That's excellent!
windexh8er 8 hours ago [-]
I think Anthropic, OpenAI and Google have proven that you can do anything with media you've purchased and/or stolen with no repercussions.
Geezus_42 8 hours ago [-]
That assumes you have a load of money.
shit_game 7 hours ago [-]
I would imagine that the discussions that these companies have had with publishers and creative houses has ammounted to what is effectively a hostage negotiation. "We can produce an infinite amount of and analogue of your product, for effectively zero money, indefinitely, and can and will win any and all court cases regarding the matter based on our wealth - please stop resisting and we will let you continue to operate".
xoxxala 7 hours ago [-]
They have different rules that don’t apply to us commoners.
edukite 7 hours ago [-]
God forbid peasants like us do this, stealing, lying and braking law in any way imaginable is reserved for rich and powerful. US orange president already gave them pass on this.
And US citizens will pay for it and take all responsibilities because of it
xbmcuser 9 hours ago [-]
As legal as plex jellyfin etc are for sharing media libraries
cgsmith 5 hours ago [-]
Understood. I just dont know how much scrutiny a project would come under with stating sharing epub files.
kidnoodle 6 hours ago [-]
Cute! I’d almost like it more for physical books really.. I don’t enjoy reading on a device these days.
You’d like a physical version of a digital version of a library?
kidnoodle 4 hours ago [-]
Hah! No, I’d like a library which is all my books and my friends and neighbours books (and maybe a way to keep track of what books I’ve loaned to people). I’ve got hundreds of books (and I do enjoy them existing in my space), might as well loan them to people so they get read, right?
raybb 3 hours ago [-]
I haven't used it myself but I think this does basically what you're asking for and seems somewhat active in my area.
scan all ISBNs of your books, look them up online to get authors&titles, put that in a list with an additional field "loaned to" and make the list accessible online (as a static page) with a yes/no flag replacing the "loaned to" field?
actually, gives me an idea for my own books! 8-D
edit: maybe keep it somewhat anonymous, if you think Fahrenheit 451 might be read as a blueprint :-/
edit2: probably is enough to dox you, with some amount of books. keep it well secret, maybe?
TristanPTY 8 hours ago [-]
Awesome
Pastookh 8 hours ago [-]
[flagged]
Rendered at 21:22:01 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time) with Vercel.
My positive spin
That said…
I think it would be better if the library cards were public keys and I set the access controls on a list of keys. The card numbering seems underbaked.
The practical problem this solves in practice is there are lots of ereaders that have opds and wifi but can’t access things over tailscale or equivalent.
I personally don't know anyone who hosts plex server of files ripped from legitimately acquired media, or anyone that uses such a server from an actual friend. If someone does, and wants to do the same for books, all the power to them.
Realistically though, I'd expect someone who doesn't buy or borrow a book (from a library, friend, or ebook from Libby) will go straight to Anna's Archive or z library. I yet need to meet someone who nicely asks their reader friend to share epub of a de-DRMed book.
(ok, in plain words, the most likely use case for this is piracy, but with more steps.)
https://grimmory.org/
I guess it's similar to lending a paper book to a friend.
More like burning a CD for a friend than sharing an album via a torrent.
And US citizens will pay for it and take all responsibilities because of it
Wonder if there’s a sensible way to plug into it for https://leafle.org
https://inventaire.io/
edit: maybe keep it somewhat anonymous, if you think Fahrenheit 451 might be read as a blueprint :-/
edit2: probably is enough to dox you, with some amount of books. keep it well secret, maybe?