NHacker Next
  • new
  • past
  • show
  • ask
  • show
  • jobs
  • submit
▲All Delta Flights Through Atlanta Delayed as Automated System Falters (nytimes.com)
36 minutes ago [-]
firsthummus 49 minutes ago [-]
It was all Delta. We had to wait for them to perform a manual weight and balance calculation before takeoff from Austin.
bri3d 39 minutes ago [-]
Likewise in Denver. They said the operators for the manual fallback are in Atlanta though, which might be some of the news confusion. It was also unclear if it was the actual weight and balance calculation or some upstream data source automation that was broken.
cogman10 23 minutes ago [-]
Animats 47 minutes ago [-]
They lost the weight and balance system? Why is that even centralized?

Some aircraft can check their own weight and balance, through sensors on the landing gear. Does Delta have that?

bri3d 35 minutes ago [-]
I’m not aware of any approved automated weight and balance system, and I’m not aware of a modern deployment of landing gear load cells.

So, that. It’s centralized because to do a decent job at guessing the weight of the plane you need all planning data (catering reloads, freight load out, bag counts) in addition to fuel load and passenger locations plus overhead bag counts. So a centralized system is a fairly logical place to fuse the data.

sam1714 17 minutes ago [-]
It was an option on the Airbus A300 back in the 80's, AFAIK nobody bought it because it was a maintenance issue.

It again became an option on the Boeing 777F [1], I also believe nobody (or very few) bought it.

There's benefit in the freight side of things because the density of stuff they deal with (plastic vs metal bricks vs some unwieldy turbine shaft) varies widely, so just eyeing it can't help detect mistakes.

[1] https://boeing.mediaroom.com/2007-03-27-Boeing-Selects-Crane...

lxgr 39 minutes ago [-]
Also beats me. I just know what for some reason, it’s apparently still commonly done via a remote application accessed by the pilots via ACARS.

Maybe it used to be too computationally intensive for onboard CPUs back when it was introduced and it was just never decentralized?

bri3d 32 minutes ago [-]
I don’t think any modern planes have calibrated/approved mechanisms for weighing themselves. I think some older freight models and conversions had load cells but they were advisory tools used to better balance the loaded cargo, not primary sources for weight and balance. I think it would be quite a regulatory and reliability feat to get automated weight approved in such a way that didn’t require doing the same manual calculations as today as a fallback. And those manual calculations are hard to decentralize because they rely on many disparate sources (catering, freight, baggage / ramp, gate crew, pilots, fuelers) that have to aggregate somewhere.
pkulak 1 hours ago [-]
So... all Delta flights then?
arwineap 1 hours ago [-]
While it's true Atlanta is a primary hub for delta, they have other hubs and many routes without Atlanta involved

For instance, Delta has something like 7 flights from Seattle to Los Angeles daily.

pkulak 48 minutes ago [-]
Thank you. Until now I thought that literally every Delta route has Atlanta as a source, destination or both. How embarrassing!
davedx 54 minutes ago [-]
[flagged]
tialaramex 20 minutes ago [-]
The Democrats just won control of both houses, so for the next two years the insistence will be that problems are caused by Congressional Democrats and most importantly by their profligate spending and refusal to address the deficit which somehow increased massively since it was last important...
Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact
Rendered at 21:20:05 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time) with Vercel.